Kimberling, the electoral college, may 1992, eleccoll. Fully editable lesson on the electoral college topics included history and background explanation pros and cons proposed reforms power point includes 10 slides. Electoral college powerpoint with cloze note handout and pro. Pros and cons of the electoral college vision launch media. The electoral college preserves the voice of states with lower populations and more rural areas, occupy theory noted. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment ratified june 15, 1804, the fourteenth amendment ratified july 1868, and the. The voters of each state, and the district of columbia, vote for electors to be the authorized constitutional members in a presidential election.
Ahh, the electoral college a source of much boredom, confusion, and frustration for americans, especially among young voters. In 2000 and 2016, the candidate who won the popular vote did not win the electoral college. Proponents of the view that one of the major advantages of the electoral college is that it. The primary purpose of this section is to show that the ecs representational unreliability is a direct consequence of our undersized house of representatives. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment ratified june 15, 1804, the fourteenth amendment ratified july 1868, and the twentythird amendment ratified mar. Students will then evaluate issues of fairness and representation with regard to the electoral college. Modern sup porters of the electoral college defend it with arguments that, according to. Lets take a look at the pros and cons of the electoral college. One benefit is that candidates dont only go to populous stateswhich would disenfranchise voters from rural and small states, each vote in a small state has.
Some are quite liberal and others are very con servative. Exploring the electoral college overview database of k12. Especially in contemporary times, urban areas tend to be more populated, but the electoral college saves the interests of. The electoral college consists of 538 electors, and an absolute majority of at. Disadvantages and advantages of electoral college connectus. For all of these reasons, it may be attractive to replace our current process with another system of indirect election that simply changes the makeup of the electoral college. Week 6 what in your opinion are the pros and cons of the. There would need to be a constitutional amendment if the compact idea doesnt work.
Because of the development of the electoral college, there was a middle option that eliminated the need to elect the president by popular vote or by. Pros and cons of the electoral college essay sample. The electoral college excerpt from an original document located at jackson county, mo election board the pros and cons of the electoral college system there have, in its 200 year history, been a number of critics and proposed reforms to the electoral college system most of them trying to eliminate it. There are pros and cons of the electoral college, which makes it. With two elections out of the last 5 as of 2016 having an electoral college winner not winning the popular vote, the pros and cons of this system are frequently debated. Relevant and engaging links to onlineresources relevant graphics talking points in notes section of ppt cloze notes 1. Nor is this concern entirely unfounded since there. Electoral college pros cons results more certain with electoral college no single region dominates with electoral college facilitates twoparty system stability directs more power to states as vital part of system greater influence to rural areas, interest groups, and minorities. If the election were based on popular vote, it would be. Aug 19, 2015 10 farreaching pros and cons of the electoral college aug 19, 2015 aug 14, 2015 by green garage during the 2012 elections in the united states, the term electoral college made headlines. The national archives and records administration nara is the federal agency responsible for coordinating activities of states and congress regarding the electoral college vote for president. Barnett, the george eastman professor of management science and one of the conference organizers, proposed a weighted vote system, which allows smaller states to retain their electoral clout.
The us electoral college is an appropriate federalstatepeople powersharing deal the united states is not a pure, popular democracy. The electoral college nc essential standards for american. A candidate could be elected without the popular vote. The electoral college is a body of electors established by the united states constitution, which forms every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the united states. Pros and cons of the electoral college there has been one faithless elector in each of the following elections. This skews significance only on sparse and small populated. Pros con of electoral college political science flashcards. Nov 10, 2016 posted in notes on the collapse and tagged cons, disenfranchise, election, electoral college, presidential, pros, pros and cons, pros and cons of the electoral college, rogue elector on 10 november 2016 by gnerphk. The total number of electors is the sum of the countrys 435 representatives, 100 senators and 3 electors from the district of columbia. Posted in notes on the collapse and tagged cons, disenfranchise, election, electoral college, presidential, pros, pros and cons, pros and cons of the electoral college, rogue elector on 10 november 2016 by gnerphk.
The pros and cons of the electoral college smartasset. Every election year sparks debate over our electoral systems legitimacy, even though few fully understand how the electoral college works or why it exists. The electoral college is a tradition of american politics thats pretty controversial. Conference weighs electoral college pros and cons mit news. Volume 4, issue 3 should the electoral college count. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Doc us electoral college pros and cons michael blugh. Even the selection of a president and the vice president has its pros and cons. The advantages of the electoral college may outweigh the. Here are some of the pros and cons of the electoral college. This would prevent one large, populous state from overly swaying a national election. The goal of the electoral college was to improve equality in voting on a national level. Several mit professors discussed ways of combining features of both a popular vote and the electoral college.
Read the following pros and cons of the electoral college. Should the system be retained, changed or discarded. There is an important debate on whether or not the electoral college should be reformed or even suppressed. Part iv highlights the advantages and disadvantages of the winner takeall. There are two main disadvantages of the electoral college. Here are some additional advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college to consider. A what are the pros and cons of the electoral college. Thinking about the political impacts of the electoral college. The electoral college is the electors from each state and it comes together every four years to select the president and the vice president of america. Electoral college socratic seminar prepare for the socratic seminar by completing the necessary readingsresearch and create an outline according to the proper format refer below with a corresponding works cited page mla format to use for reference during the seminar. Electoral college in order to gain a better understanding of how americans elect the president. Some say the electoral college is key to maintaining whats good about u. Finally, students will participate in a class debate over the pros and cons of the current system.
Students should consider the information youve learned about the electoral college, including the pros and cons to the system. Is this the best method of electing the president of the united states. The us constitution limits power between various entities, including the people, the federal government, and state governments. Here are some of the arguments for and against the electoral college. Oct 20, 2008 several mit professors discussed ways of combining features of both a popular vote and the electoral college. As the results of the 2016 election unravel, more people than ever are questioning the role of the electoral college and its suitability in todays political system. What are the pros and cons of the electoral college. The electoral college is a defender of the equal rights of states and the rights of citizens of the states. The trouble with the electoral college cities, metro areas, elections and the united states duration. An interesting point to this discussion is that many of the pros are argued by some to be disadvantages, and many of the cons are believed to be the advantages of the system by others. Numerous movements have aimed to go from an electoral college to a popular election, but the system remains. The founding fathers devised the electoral college to elect the president but they did not anticipate the emergence of national political parties or a communications network able to bring presidential candidates before the entire electorate.
If you are in favor of changes, what changes would you suggest. I saw this video by the well liked by reddit youtuber cgp grey, he makes pretty good points on how the electoral college is flawed and what not. Lastly, circle the numbers of the specific arguments that you find the most convincing on the side that you agree with. The electoral college system, long a source of controversy, came under especially heavy criticism after the 2016 presidential election when republican donald trump lost the nationwide popular vote to democrat hillary clinton by over 2. The electoral college guarantees certainty to the outcome of the presidential election. Reforming the electoral college with the districtpopular plan. The electoral college overview in this lesson, students will examine.
The electoral college is one of the many compromises written into the t united states constitution in 1787. What, in your opinion, are the pros and cons of the electoral college system in american politics. Consider the information youve learned about the electoral college, including the pros and cons to the system. With the divide between democrats and republicans currently in place, the likelihood that this idea will receive any movement any time soon is quite minimal. Pdf the birth of 1992 democracy in ghana has called for a multiparty participation in ghanas electoral system. The pros and cons of abolishing the electoral college must go beyond the 65% of people who want it gone.
Nov 14, 2016 ahh, the electoral college a source of much boredom, confusion, and frustration for americans, especially among young voters. The establishment of the electoral college system truly has both pros and cons, which you should be aware of so you will know where you stand. The pros and cons of the electoral college youtube. Nov 23, 2004 popular vote, the electoral college tends to exaggerate the margin of victory, thus discouraging post electoral challenges and diminishing uncertainty. Then decide if you think that the electoral college should remain or be abolished. The fec has no jurisdiction over the electoral college. Dec 20, 2016 provided in many of the hyperlinks is information to help inform your opinion about the effectiveness of the electoral college. The fundamental concern with the electoral college is its representational unreliability. Pros and cons of the electoral college today, many people think that the electoral college should be abolished and that the total popular vote should determine the president. In spite of these contradictions, there are the pros and cons of the american electoral college. Electoral college is a complicated and undemocratic system as viewed by some. Pros and cons of the electoral college by corey bishop on prezi.
159 1337 431 1105 807 898 1123 482 88 982 1458 1351 331 1194 281 1272 1221 732 1508 1259 456 55 273 433 249 66 1113 753 1135 772 1242 1002 689